Friday, April 10, 2009

Documentary Review: Unnatural Causes

This week we watched the documentary "Unnatural Causes." At the start of the documentary the listed off some interesting facts.
-The U.S. spends $2 trillion dollars a year on medical care.  That is about half that is spent world wide each year.
-Even though we spend a lot of money on health care we are still at #30 for life expectancy, which means we live shorter/sicker lives than other countries.
-There are 47 million Americans that go without health care.
-Social Influences affect health.



With just these few facts I feel that I learned a lot.  I couldn't believe that we were ranked 30 for health care, and we spend the most money on it.  That makes me wonder who is getting all the health care that we are spending so much on.  In the movie it focused on St.Louis.  They have done many studies in the different districts of St.Louis to show how money correlates with your health.  The higher your salary, the nicer neighborhood you live in, and the more power you have, essentially equals better health.  

Health and wealth hasn't just been compared in St.Louis.  In France, the minimum wage is twice as much as ours, they get more vacation time, and invest in better education systems.  So, the countries that distribute their wealth better have better health.

Throughout the movie the message that kept popping up in my mind is that Power=Money=Better Health.  All the studies that were done, no matter where they were done, always showed that those at the top of the ladder had better health that those at the bottom.  It made me think of how in America, "the land of opportunities", we have such wide range of incomes and it is really hard to move your way up if you don't have those resources available to you.  The documentary followed a few different families, one being the wealthier family, as he was a CEO.  They lived in a nice neighborhood with big yards and trees, and where the people felt safe and had places to go for walks.  He and the others in his district were rated with the best health and life expectancy of 79. It continued to follow a woman who is a Lab supervisor, middle-class, and lives in a fairly good neighborhood.  She lives in a nicer house, has a yard, and feels safe.  The life expectancy for her district is 75. Then it followed a lower middle-class family living in a poorer district, where the houses were closer together, didn't have much of a yard, and didn't feel as safe.  He worked a full time job as well as his wife and they were just making it.  They said the only way they could ever try to move is if one of them got a 2nd job, which would then increase the stress level and cause more health risks.  The people living in this district had a poorer level of health and only have a life expectancy of 73.  Finally it went to an even poorer district.  They followed a woman who lives on $200 dollars a month for groceries to feed her, her husband, and 3 children, and not much more for anything else.  She currently doesn't have a job and her husband is disabled. She doesn't feel safe in her neighborhood and the houses are so close you could touch the one next to it. The life expectancy in her district is 70.

My Thoughts
In my summary I was trying to get my point through that there is a correlation there that can't be ignored.  Money=Power and with Power it seems that you have better health.  I think this documentary really opened my eyes. I had no idea that there was even research going on for this type of thing.  It seems really logical when the information is laid out in front of you, but it isn't something that I think crosses many peoples minds.  It is definitely something that needs to be exposed to make people aware. 
Things to think about:
-Why is the U.S. ranked so low, even thought we spend so much money on our health care.
-What is being done about the issues?
-What are some ways that we can better our health care system, so people can live at a more equal level?

Here is a link to the documentaries website.  It has a lot of good information on there.  It even shows some case studies that are being done right now! 
http://www.unnaturalcauses.org/transcripts.php

24 comments:

  1. Kaileigh-
    Great post!I also couldn't believe that we were ranked 30 for health care. I think that we have a lot of work to do to ensure the availability of healthy resources. I think that it's crazy how money influences everything around us. If you have money that influences your power and authority. If someone doesn't have money, what's going got happen in the future? Keep up the great work!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Kaleigh,
    Good post, not really sure that the movie was a bout St.Louis, but either way, you points are valid if we are spending soo much money on our health and we are still #30 on "the List" then maybe we have to make some changes.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Kaleigh- I liked the facts that you started this blog off with. I CANT BELIEVE THE US SPENDS 2 TRILLION DOLLARS IN HEALTH CARE A YEAR! That number is literally astronomical! It's pretty ridiculous that we spend so much yet we are still 30th in life expectancy for the world. Clearly we have some problems.
    After watching this documentary I would agree that the problems are in our socioeconomic culture we basically force the people of our nation into. However, what nation isn't separated by classes? I am unsure if any are...
    I think you are a genius when you say: money=power. Its sad. Its true.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Nice Post Kaileigh!
    This documentary opened my eyes as well. Like you said, it is something that doesn't really cross my mind. I agree with you more people should be informed to become more aware, it would really make a difference in various ways, I think .
    I really liked the questions you asked when closing, it really had me thinking. I wonder what's really being done about this issue.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Good review!
    I liked that you included those facts at the beginning - I, too, thought it was shocking that the U.S. spends $2 trillion/yr on health care and judging by our life expectancy and infant mortality rates we don't have a whole lot to show for all that spending!
    Also, nice job stressing the "Health=Wealth" concept. I feel this is definitely a huge problem in the U.S., and this documentary reinforced that opinion for me.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Good review!
    Its sad to think that money=power which in turn equals better health. I also liked how you pointed out that the US is ranked 30 for health care and the fact that we pour so much money into it. I agree it really gets me thinking on who is receiving the majority of the health care benefits?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Kailiegh

    Great review! First of all, I was floored at the fact that the US spends $2 Trillion on Health Care.You would think that we could be a little higher than 30 in the rankings with a number like that! I also can't believe that France is doing something that seems so great,and the US can't seem to even follow in part of there ideas.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hey Kailiegh,
    Great Post, it doesn't seem right that power=money=better health I think we all deserve the same health care no matter how big our pay checks are. Another thing that made me wonder was that we spend $2 trillion on health care every year yet more of our babies are dying and were still ranked #30 for life expectancy...something is not adding up. The U.S. definately needs to get working on some better ways to distribute health...good job on your review

    ReplyDelete
  9. You bring up a lot of great questions Kaileigh. I think it would be really smart for our country to look into what other countries are doing that their health is so great compared to ours... Wealth should not have to equal health!

    ReplyDelete
  10. We did get a lot of information that is quite staggering from this video. There should be more studies done to back up the documentaries' claims that more power and money equal better health and life expectancey. I also wonder if the majority of 3trillion money is being spent on the upper levels of social class or if it is being spread out amongist the everyone. Maybe America is better at trying to use preventative health care measures which boosts up our costs. It would be nice to see where the 3 trillion is going both if richer patients are getting the treatments, or if we are just sloppy with our money and spend it on health care we don't need.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hey Kaileigh!

    This review really had me thinking about so many factors! I was shocked to see the clear results of the studies with the correlation of money to health. How the CEO's are living longer and healthier than the families struggling to make ends meet. This is so unfair and such a shocking statistic! I am learning a trend in this class: POWER and MONEY controls so many factors when it comes to environmental health!! Good questions at the end of your review, I am not really sure of the answers to them, but keeps me thinking!!
    Good job Kail!!

    Kathy

    ReplyDelete
  12. Kaileigh,
    Awesome job! I especially liked your comment, "It (the correlation between health and wealth) is definitely something that needs to be exposed to make people aware." I think this task definitely falls within health educator's responsibility of advocacy. Your review really made me think!

    ReplyDelete
  13. I also did a review on this documentary, and I found the same things as you. Wealth=Power, and Power ends up influencing health. I also found this movie to be incredibly interesting. I knew that wealth influenced health, but I honestly had no idea how much. I was also shocked by the fact that we are ranked 30th for life expectancy, when we are spending the amount that we are on health care. There are some obvious issues here, and I think that it is about time we start looking into some solutions.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Kaileight-

    Get review. You hit lots of great points that were discussed in the film. It's unfortunate that majority of the films we have watched are based on environmental factors related to money.. Like you said money=power and thats what everyone is striving for. It's sad in this case that it can go as far as affect peoples health. Some of the statistics they had were extremely shocking.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Kaileigh,
    The U.S. spends $2 trillion dollars a year on medical care. That is about half that is spent world wide each year. What an amazing fact dont you think.... it really made me kinda frustrated!:) man its shocking! I agree that you are right on in saying that there is a correlation between health and wealth that cannot be denied!!!:) Great work!

    ReplyDelete
  16. I don't get that either...30th in the ranks. When we spend nearly 2 trillion on health care. Spending that kind of money we should almost guarantee people they will live at least a couple years longer than expected. But of course in a field like health care many feel there should not be a price placed on health of a nation. Good review Kaileigh.

    ReplyDelete
  17. This documentary definitely opened my eyes to how power=money=better health as well. It's unfortunate how much power money has. Great job summarizing this documentary!

    ReplyDelete
  18. Great review! It is really crazy how the more money you have the more power you have to keep yourself healthy. The way they broke down the neighborhoods was a really clear way to show the contrasts of money and health.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Good job!!! Your review really got me thinking about a lot of factors...like we are ranked 3oth!!!??what! You would think we would be one of the trop ranked since we have so much medical care and access to resources that help us live..crazy thought!

    ReplyDelete
  20. Hey Kaileigh,

    You ask some really great questions at the end of your post! I really agree with you on how while watching the video, it imprints the idea that money=power=better health. And like you said, it all seems to make sense when watching the video, but if I never watched it, I would be completely unaware of this issue! Hopefully America will figure out what needs to be done so that everyone, especially the poorer population, can have equal healthcare!

    ReplyDelete
  21. Hey Kaileigh,

    Good job on this post!!! I can't believe how much money plays in effect of people's health! It's scary how much stress controls our immune system and overall health. Overall, great job=)

    ReplyDelete
  22. Kalieigh~ Great post you made some pretty good points!! It really is sad that he who has the money has the power! Its sad but so true! It really does not surprise me on that we are rank 30th in health care but what is sad that we really are not doing that much to improve it either...other countries are so why cant we do it!!

    ReplyDelete
  23. I thought it was shocking that our country was rated 30 for health care, and we pay the most!? It really makes no sense to me...
    You had a good review that flows well and ties in your personal thoughts!

    ReplyDelete
  24. Great post Kaleigh. I agree that this topic is one that is a bit new to me as well. I had heard about it breifly before, but not into this much detail, and I am glad we got to be led to this eye opening issue.

    ReplyDelete