Monday, March 2, 2009

Reading Review:III Winds: The Chemical Plant Next Door


This article was written by Becky Bradway. It starts off talking about her life growing up in Buffalo, Illinois. She talks about living in a small town and how much she loved it, because she didn't have a care in the world. She admits that she didn't realize all of the "grown-up" issues that her parents and other adults in the town were facing. Buffalo is actually being polluted by a chemical plant right down the road, Borden.

Borden and Buffalo

Borden is the chemical plant that is only a little ways from Buffalo, where Becky and her family lived. Her mom got sick and Becky was sure it was from the chemical wastes that Borden was putting into the water. There were fish dying and floating in the water. People from Buffalo and other towns surrounding Borden were the ones working there and supplying the wastes into the water. People around there didn't have much of a choice; it was a job! Little towns yield little power, and many kids growing up there think they should lead the life their parents did. By going to work at the factory, have children, then their children have children and so on.


Relics Remain

Even years after living there the towns remained the same. Borden was now specializing in resins and formaldehyde, Elmer's glue and a type of saran wrap. Years ago the plant used to produce milk. What is scary is that the plastic wrap we use goes into the food when you microwave it and Elmer's glue would have non-toxic levels of some chemicals. The plant also produces polyvinyl chloride (PVC), which is used in tile, plastic water pipes, siding, and wire insulation. People who work in the plant making PVC have higher rates of breast and liver cancer. PVC can stay in the water that they pollute for decades and gets into the fish. The plant has been sued several times for the amount of stuff they claim they "accidently" polluted into the water and air. Borden also owns other plants throughout the country, and they also cause many problems. Not counting accidents, the plant releases 65,000 pounds of vinyl chloride and 40,000 pounds of vinyl acetate into Central Illinois air every year!


Blue-Collar Risks

Even those who didn't work for the factory faced harships with their jobs. Becky's family owned their own construction business, but that can be very hard on the body. They never could get away from the plants pollutions though. They had to drink the water and breathe the air. Although Borden isn't the only plant causing pollution into the river, it does its fair share. It is killing many fish in the water and is causing many people to get cancer and die, including Becky's mother and uncle.


My Thoughts

I am surprised that these plants are allowed to dump as much as 800,000 pounds a day of pollution into the water. I don't understand how the government agencies allow it. Also the pollution seems to be linked to the increase of certain cancers in that area, so I think that something should be done about it. I am also from a small town of about 1,200 people and I understand what she says when people just repeat what their parents do. I like to call it getting stuck in the small town "rut," but I don't really agree with her. There are so many opportunities and ways that you can achieve them these days that I don't think living in a small town and being stuck in those ways is an excuse. Someone from those towns should try and do something about it and get involved to help fix the problem!
Links
This link is really neat. You can click on any of the topics and it will give you information regulations and laws for chemical plants. I especialla like the Environmental Protection Agency link! http://people.clarkson.edu/~wilcox/Design/refsafe.htm

Vocabulary:

Resins: Any of various yellowish viscous liquids or soft solids of plant origin; used in lacquers, varnishes and many other applications.

Herbicides: A herbicide is used to kill unwanted plants. Selective herbicides kill specific targets while leaving the desired crop relatively unharmed.

Pesticides: A substance or mixture of substances used to kill a pest. A pesticide may be a chemical substance, biological agent (such as a virus or bacteria), antimicrobial, disinfectant or device used against any pest.

Industrial Chemicals: Comprises the companies that produce industrial chemicals. It is central to modern world economy, converting raw materials (oil, natural gas, air, water, metals, minerals) into more than 70,000 different products.


22 comments:

  1. I am also surprised that these plants are allowed to dump as much as 800,000 pounds a day of pollution into the water!!! What the heck are they thinking? When we already know from previous articles and documentaries that there is a serious fresh water shortage. And it's so sad that so many people are getting cancer in that small town. It's hard not to assume a correlation between the factories and illnesses like cancer. Good Post, Kaileigh=)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great post Kaileigh! It's rediculous how much these plants are allowed to dump into the streams! But I also wonder, if the gov't made it illegal to do this, where would all the waste go? It has to go somewhere, and people need these products that are being made by these plants, so we are stuck in a dirty mess. I also agree with you to a point that "small-town" people have opportunities to 'get away' but I do think some people may be stuck too. I think money can be a big factor, but also age (kids can't really move by themselves). But yeah, the idea that everyone is stuck in a small city is not true in my opinion. Good post!

    ReplyDelete
  3. It's terrible that these plans dump so much pollution in the water! I agree with you that the people in the town should try to get involved and do something about it. Great job on your post!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think it's crazy that 800,000 tons of waste is being dumped into local water supplies. You're right, people need to fix the problem. Small towns can make huge differences. I'm from a small town and couldn't imagine if I was living in these conditions. Way to go Kaileigh

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hey Kaileigh! Really liked your summary! They're always so easy to read! And I also really liked your 'Relics Remain' section and everything about the PVC! Great job with the links too! Have a good one!

    Steve

    ReplyDelete
  6. Kaileigh!
    That is scary that the saran wraps and glues are used and could harms us!
    I liked how in class you discussed that from a personal level, you know what it is like to be from a rural area. It makes you think from a different viewpoint! and I agree, unfortunately many people feel stuck in that "rut". It seems like everyone does what is comfortable for them!
    I hope this can get figured out!!

    Kathy

    ReplyDelete
  7. Kaileigh,
    Your quote, "There are so many opportunities and ways that you can achieve them these days that I don't think living in a small town and being stuck in those ways is an excuse," really caught my attention.

    Maybe older generations didn't have the opportunities and resources that we grew up with. Most people from the author's generation probably weren't expected to leave town and go to college. Nowdays, it's isn't a question of IF we are going to college, it is a question of WHERE. Hopefully our generation can help pave the way for environmentally-friendly change in small communities!

    ReplyDelete
  8. kaileigh-

    I really enjoyed reading your post! All your points held lots of information and it summed up the article nicely. 800,000 pounds of waste is madness! Just thinking about how much that adds up ovr the years makes me disgusted. Also, I like the point you made about living in a small town. In some cases it is a trend to do what you know best and if you come from a working family that lives off income from the mill, you might follow in those tracks, but that doesn't necessiarly mean someone is "stuck" working there.

    ReplyDelete
  9. The numbers throughout this article are shocking... I agree with you that a person controls their own destination, and if they're going to stay in the same small town, why wouldn't they try and do something about their towns problems? If you feel "stuck" somewhere, it should be time to evaluate your opportunities!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Kaleigh,
    Good review! I was also taken back by the amount of pollution that is allowed to be dumped into the water. Scarier than that is that is just one plant! How many others are there doing the same thing?

    ReplyDelete
  11. Kaileigh

    Great review!
    I was really surprised as well that companies are allowed to dump that much into the water. So mamy everyday things that we use are so bad for us we are slowly finding out that it is scary to find out what they may have been doing to us. I really liked the terms that you put, as I didn't know formal definitions for any of them. Great Review :)

    Heather

    ReplyDelete
  12. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Good review, Kaileigh! I, too, was blown away by the amount of pollution that is allowed for these companies! You also made a good point saying that there are available opportunities for people to break the small-town cycle, but unfortunately I don't think everyone is able to take advantage of these chances.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Very good post Kaileigh. This was an interesting review to read, heartfelt and intimate. I thought it was good that she told the story of her family to make it more personal and not so scientific, like the other articles. I agree with you though on the idea of how it isnt right to 'blame' being from a small town on the ways in which they are harming the environment. Nice job :)

    ReplyDelete
  15. Good review Kaileigh.
    One thing that shocked to most while reading you post was that "Not counting accidents, the plant releases 65,000 pounds of vinyl chloride and 40,000 pounds of vinyl acetate into Central Illinois air every year!" Wow that's scary! Once again the US government isn't doing much to help all these innocent people. The more I learn in this class, the more i realize the gov doesn't do much to help improve our environment.

    Nice job!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Kaliegh-
    Good review of the reading. I thought you understood it very well. I also liked how you started off the discussion in class today. I feel like the author was more concerned about telling a story than giving facts and motivating people to act on changing the things that need to be changed.
    I am also from a small town, but not as small as yours! I totally agree that in this day and age, there isnt much of an excuse to just continue doing what your parents do. Although we can't speak for everyone who gets stuck in the "small town rut" as you termed it, there are plenty of opportunities to al least TRY something else. Maybe they go back to that area and just continue doing what their parents did, but with all of the opportunities we have, I would like to see more small town people actively pursue a future that is more promising than factory work.
    Great job! --S

    ReplyDelete
  17. Nice review Kaliegh! I agree with you that it shouldn't be an excuse of living in a small town to not be able an escape from that situation. 800,000 pounds of pollution a day being dumped into the nearby river is absolutely terrible. You would think that there would be regulations the control the amount of pollution to be dumped a day. A number like that I think would be the cause of numerous cancer cases.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I thought it was really scary too on how much damage they really do. I just think that the people in these small towns don't know anything else but the life they are in. Also I don't think they are aware that there are these resources out there to help them out of these situations.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Nice review. I honestly did not know that suran wrap gets into foods when you microwaved them, and to think that 800,000 pounds of pollution with any consequences is just wrong on so many levels.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Great post! I really like how you ended your review by voicing your opinion on getting stuck in the small town "rut". I think that you are able to understand this issue on a much deeper level than me, a city girl. I agree that there are more opportunities now, so staying in your small town, to die from chemicle poisoning shouldn't happen, but it still does. Some people just don't have the money or abilities to get out, so instead they do have to follow in their parents' footsteps. This is really sad to me.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Great post!
    First thing first, I think the picture that you added has a really big impact! I like how you spoke about blue collar risks.. and the hardships that they face simply because life did not offer them the chance to get away this is what they have to do to live! It was a really great eye opener for me ! Great job this week!

    ReplyDelete
  22. Kaileigh,

    I like your link to what is formaldhyde. 800,00 pounds is a lot of pollution for a year, but this is the statistic for one day. Wow I never would want to let such pollution him my rivers. The animal life would all die off, and then what do you have? Without nature/animals the earth would be a very boring place. It is good that you mentioned that people in a small town should try and not become complacent with the way things are run in that town. Yes, people can make a change if you ban together and work for it.

    ReplyDelete